ALL OUR INVENTORY IS GUARANTEED 100% AUTHENTIC! IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE IT IS... SEND IT BACK! (must be untested)

Since many of our items are rare and discontinued quantities are limited! If you are interested in anything in particular please don't hesitate to email us at BeauteBay@yahoo.com. We usually respond within 12-24 hours.

NOTE: To Make the Image of the Item Bigger so You Can See the Colors Better, Just Click on It!

Cover Girl

All Cover Girl Items Now Reduced! Most items under $2! Many items are under $1!

CoverGirl Natureluxe Gloss Balm SPF 15 in Tulip - Discontinued Item
$4.95
covergirl-natureluxe-tulip
CoverGirl Natureluxe Gloss Balm SPF 15 in Muscat - Discontinued Item
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
covergirl-natureluxe-muscat
Cover Girl Stack-Ups Lip Swirl in Rootbeer Float
Retail Price: $3.50
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-stackups-rootbeer
Cover Girl Stack-Ups All Over Color in BareBlush
Retail Price: $3.50
Our Price: $1.25
cover-girl-stackups-bareblush
Cover Girl Shadow Squease in Latte - NIB - Discontinued
Retail Price: $6.50
Our Price: $3.00
cover-girl-shadow-squease-latte
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Heat
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.95
covergirl-shineblast-heat
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Radiate
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.75
cover-girl-shineblast-radiate
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Sparkler
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.75
cover-girl-shineblast-sparkler
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Smolder
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.95
covergirl-shineblast-smolder
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Firecracker
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.75
covergirl-shineblast-firecracker
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Ablaze
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.75
covergirl-shineblast-ablaze
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Flare
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.25
covergirl-shineblast-flare
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Fire
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.75
covergirl-shineblast-fire
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Ignite
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.75
covergirl-shineblast-ignite
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Aglow
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.50
covergirl-shineblast-aglow
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Beam
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.50
covergirl-shineblast-beam
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Dazzle
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.25
covergirl-shineblast-dazzle
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Ember
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.25
covergirl-shineblast-ember
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Shineblast Lipgloss in Glimmer
Retail Price: $3.95
Our Price: $1.25
covergirl-shineblast-glimmer
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Everbloom Kiss
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $2.50
cover-girl-outlast-everbloom-kiss
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Cinnamon
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $2.50
cover-girl-outlast-cinnamon
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Teasing Blush
Retail Price: $6.00
Our Price: $2.95
cover-girl-outlast-teasing-blush
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Bit of Blossom
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $2.50
cover-girl-outlast-bit-of-blossom
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Sassy Mauve
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $2.95
cover-girl-outlast-sassy-mauve
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Flirty Nude
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $2.50
cover-girl-outlast-flirty-nude
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Berry Smooch
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $2.50
cover-girl-outlast-berry-smooch
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Wild Berry Wink
Retail Price: $4.49
Our Price: $1.95
cover-girl-outlast-wild-berry-wink
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Outlast Lipstain in Plum Pout
Retail Price: $6.00
Our Price: $2.95
cover-girl-outlast-plum-pout
Cover Girl Wetslicks Lip Gloss in Glamourpuss Star - Limited Edition
$6.50
cover-girl-glamourpuss
Cover Girl Wetslicks Crystals Lip Gloss in Bubble
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-crystals-bubble
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Crystals Lip Gloss in Chocofix
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-crystals-chocofix
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Crystals Lip Gloss in Sassy
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-crystals-sassy
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Lip Gloss in Patently Pink
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $2.95
cover-girl-patently-pink
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Lip Gloss in Pink Sequin
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-pink-sequin
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Everything's Rosy
$4.95
cover-girl-amazemint-everythingrosy
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Pink Positive
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-amazemint-pink-positive
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Sillylily
Retail Price: $8.50
Our Price: $6.50
cover-girl-amazemint-sillylily
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Toast-ed
Retail Price: $6.50
Our Price: $4.50
cover-girl-amazemint-toasted
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Freedom of Peach
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $2.75
cover-girl-amazemint-peach
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Plum Crazy
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-mazemint-plum-crazy
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Un-Wined
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $3.50
cover-girl-amazemint-unwined
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Tickled Pink
$4.95
cover-girl-amazemint-tickled-pink
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Merry Berry
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $2.75
cover-girl-amazemint-merry
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Slaphappy
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $2.75
cover-girl-amazemint-slaphappy
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Amazemint Gloss in Happy Hour
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $2.75
cover-girl-amazemint-happy-hour
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Fruit Spritzers in Grape Splash
Retail Price: $6.50
Our Price: $4.50
cover-girl-wetslicks-grape
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Wetslicks Fruit Spritzers in Tangerine Splash
Retail Price: $4.50
Our Price: $2.95
cover-girl-wetslicks-tangerine
Cover Girl Wetslicks Fruit Spritzers in Lemon Splash
Retail Price: $4.50
Our Price: $2.50
cover-girl-wetslicks-lemon
Cover Girl Wetslicks Fruit Spritzers Lip Gloss in Cool Cocoa Mint Splash
Retail Price: $9.95
Our Price: $8.50
cover-girl-wetslicks-cocoa-gloss
Cover Girl Wetslicks Fruit Spritzers Lip Gloss in Caramel Apple Splash
$6.95
cover-girl-wetslicks-gloss-caramel
Cover Girl Refillable Magnetic Custom Compact
Retail Price: $4.95
Our Price: $2.50
covergirl-compact-empty
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Refillable Magnetic Custom Compact Starter Kit
Retail Price: $5.95
Our Price: $3.50
covergirl-magnetic-compact
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Bistro Burgundy
Retail Price: $1.50
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-burgundy
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in In the Nude
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-nude
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Vintage Wine
Retail Price: $1.50
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-wine
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Smokey Rose
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-smokey-rose
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Daring
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-daring
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Warm Brick
Retail Price: $1.50
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-warm-brick
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Parisian Pink
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-parisian-pink
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Midnight Mauve
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-midnight-mauve
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Bronzed Peach
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-bronzed-peach
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Demure
Retail Price: $1.50
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-demure
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in IceBlue Pink
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-lip-color-iceblue-pink
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Natural Frost
Retail Price: $1.50
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-natural-frost
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Rose Cashmere
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-rose-cashmere
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Pink Chic
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-pink-chic
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Sugar Almond
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-sugar-almond
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Princess
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-princess
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Hipster
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-hipster
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Pure Gloss
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-pure-gloss
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Clear
Retail Price: $1.50
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-clear
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Brandyberry
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.50
cover-girl-lip-color-brandyberry
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in It's Your Mauve
Retail Price: $1.75
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-lip-color-your-mauve
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Bronze Goddess
Retail Price: $2.00
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-lip-color-bronze-goddess
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Really Red
Retail Price: $2.50
Our Price: $1.25
cover-girl-lip-color-really-red
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Classic Red
Retail Price: $2.50
Our Price: $1.25
cover-girl-lip-color-classic-red
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Iced Mauve
Retail Price: $2.50
Our Price: $1.25
cover-girl-lip-color-iced-mauve
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Lip Color Pot in Rose Quartz
Retail Price: $2.00
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-lip-color-rose-quartz
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in MauveBerry
Retail Price: $2.00
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-eyecolor-mauveberry
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in Shimmering Onyx
Retail Price: $2.00
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-eyecolor-onyx
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in Swiss Chocolate
Retail Price: $2.00
Our Price: $0.75
cover-girl-eyecolor-swiss-chocolate
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in Mink
Retail Price: $2.00
Our Price: $1.00
cover-girl-eyecolor-mink
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in Pink Chiffon
Retail Price: $2.25
Our Price: $1.25
cover-girl-eyecolor-pin-chiffon
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in Snow Blossom
Retail Price: $2.50
Our Price: $1.50
cover-girl-eyecolor-snow-blossom
This item is currently out of stock!
Cover Girl Magnetic Eye Color Pot in Tapestry Taupe
Retail Price: $2.50
Our Price: $1.50
cover-girl-eyecolor-taupe
This item is currently out of stock!
ALTHOUGH SOME ITEMS ARE LISTED AS OUT OF STOCK WE ARE ADDING NEW ITEMS BI-WEEKLY. MANY NEW ITEMS ARE NOW AVAILABLE! IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN SOMETHING IN PARTICULAR, HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR FAVORITE ITEM (if we still have it, or if we will have it again) OR IF YOU WOULD LIKE US TO HOLD A SPECIFIC ITEM FOR YOU PLEASE EMAIL US AND LET US KNOW! THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE.

NOTE: we have many items that we have only one piece of that are not listed on the site. please don't hesitate to email us if you don't see your favorite here. we may have it! email: beautebay@yahoo.com